IRS Settlement with Atheist Groups Threatens Free Speech in Churches


American Pastors Network Says Settlement Is Wake-Up Call for Pastors and Churches


PHILADELPHIA—The Internal Revenue Service has settled a lawsuit with the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF), and as a result, the IRS will adopt standards to determine whether churches and religious organizations have violated restrictions on political activity.

The details of the settlement have not been released but the IRS has said it will amend its policies to enforce tax laws on what FFRF calls “rogue political churches.”

American Pastors Network (APN, says the new development should serve as a wake-up call for pastors in every pulpit who cherish First Amendment rights.

“As a result of this settlement,” said APN President Sam Rohrer, “the Justice Department, according to its own statement, will begin to crack down on political speech from the pulpit. This is literally a call to arms and should not be taken as idle commentary but as a warning shot across the bow. With this decision, pastors’ freedom of speech from the pulpit is in danger. This is perhaps one of the greatest urgencies and motivations for the establishment of state chapters within the American Pastors Network, so pastors can come together and unite on important issues such as these. There is nothing stronger than speaking with unity and strength as pastors address the real issues of the day.”

In the case, FFRF demanded that the Johnson Amendment, a controversial IRS code added in 1954 that precludes nonprofit organizations from engaging in campaign activity, be enforced against churches.

Rohrer said implications of the settlement could mean that churches cannot distribute voter guides to congregations, and pastors may not be able to talk from the pulpit about political issues in relation to the Bible.

Erik Stanley, an attorney with Alliance Defending Freedom, said the IRS settlement with the atheist group should create concern, telling The Blaze, “Every American should fear an IRS that uses its vast power to target, threaten and punish political opponents. Churches have succumbed to this regime of fear for the last 60 years under the Johnson Amendment, which was added to the tax code specifically to silence speech a politician didn’t like.”

ADF has been a longtime opponent of FFRF and has organized the annual “Pulpit Freedom Sunday” event, set this year for October 5.

The settlement comes directly in the middle of the IRS scandal that found that the tax agency was unfairly targeting conservative organizations.

1 reply
  1. Timothy E. Holloway
    Timothy E. Holloway says:

    Good morning Sam,

    What specific actions do you recommend? Perhaps pastor Keith Tucci would be willing to endorse from the pulpit as a test case and we can litigate it through the system. Keith has done this before but the IRS didn’t take the bait. If he openly endorsed from the pulpit, we recorded the video and posted it on Utube the IRS would have to put up or shut up. I say the best defense is a powerful offense. Perhaps we could line up financial and legal support prior to the act that we would be totally prepared with press releases, attorney briefs etc. and take it to the IRS and the Holder Justice Dept. I’m fed up with this liberal and evil government. The constitution guarantees the right to public worship and expression. The constitution is a simple contract between those who govern and the governed. If the contract is breached and broken by either party, the other party can declare the contract null and void. If the government re-writes the contract in the courts then we, the people, can say it no longer applies and we are no longer obligated to obey its authority or fund it with taxes. Let’s revolt!
    In Christ,


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *